1921
Ottawa Senators
Jack Darragh
Pete Green

1920
Ottawa Senators
Jack Darragh
Pete Green

1919

1918
Toronto Arenas
Corb Denneny

1917
Seattle Metropolitans
Pete Muldoon

1916
Montreal Canadiens
George Kennedy

1915
Vancouver Millionaires
Frank Patrick

1914
Toronto Blueshirts
Scotty Davidson

1913
Quebec Bulldogs
Joe Malone

1912
Quebec Bulldogs
C. Nolan

1911
Ottawa Senators
Bruce Stuart

1910
Montreal Wanderers
Pud Glass