1909
Ottawa Senators
Bruce Stuart

1908
Montreal Wanderers
Cecil Blachford

1907
Montreal Wanderers
Cecil Blachford
Kenora Thistles
Tommy Philips

1906
Montreal Wanderers
Cecil Blachford
Ottawa Silver Seven
A. T. Smith

1905
Ottawa Silver Seven
A. T. Smith

1904
Ottawa Silver Seven
A. T. Smith

1903
Ottawa Silver Seven
A. T. Smith
Montreal A. A. A.
C. McKerrow

1902
Montreal A. A. A.
C. McKerrow
Winnipeg Victorias
D. H. Bain

1901
Winnipeg Victorias
D. H. Bain